The following plays have been produced during the Heart of America Shakespeare Festival's past fourteen seasons:

2006	King Henry V	Director: Sidonie Garrett
2005	Much Ado About Nothing	Director: Sidonie Garrett
2004	Julius Caesar	Director: Sidonie Garrett
2003	Hamlet	Director: Sidonie Garrett
2002	Taming of the Shrew A Midsummer Night's Dream	Director: Sidonie Garrett Director: Ian Wooldridge
2001	The Tempest Twelfth Night	Director: Ian Wooldridge Director: Sidonie Garrett
2000	King Lear As You Like It	Director: Bruce Levitt Director: Mark Robbins
1999	Macbeth Much Ado About Nothing	Director: Bruce Levitt Director: Benny Ambush
1998	Love's Labour's Lost Measure for Measure	Director: Bruce Levitt Director: Bruce Levitt
1997	King Richard III	Director: Bruce Levitt
1996	Romeo and Juliet	Director: Bruce Levitt
1995	The Taming of the Shrew	Director: Melia Bensussen
1994	A Midsummer Night's Dream	Director: Vincent Dowling
1993	The Tempest	Director: Eberle Thomas